The Fort Worth Press - EU's legal weapon facing the heat from US big tech

USD -
AED 3.673025
AFN 71.548685
ALL 89.774885
AMD 390.742248
ANG 1.790208
AOA 916.000304
ARS 1074.379902
AUD 1.600794
AWG 1.8
AZN 1.69782
BAM 1.768195
BBD 2.01763
BDT 121.408553
BGN 1.761997
BHD 0.376924
BIF 2969.894223
BMD 1
BND 1.335232
BOB 6.904439
BRL 5.633598
BSD 0.999277
BTN 85.310551
BWP 13.830576
BYN 3.270138
BYR 19600
BZD 2.007233
CAD 1.409755
CDF 2873.000032
CHF 0.8552
CLF 0.024745
CLP 949.560009
CNY 7.28155
CNH 7.25325
COP 4153.75
CRC 503.480698
CUC 1
CUP 26.5
CVE 99.688093
CZK 22.656696
DJF 177.940512
DKK 6.739485
DOP 63.104602
DZD 132.973986
EGP 50.594602
ERN 15
ETB 131.535666
EUR 0.903285
FJD 2.314904
FKP 0.770718
GBP 0.764025
GEL 2.750171
GGP 0.770718
GHS 15.488654
GIP 0.770718
GMD 71.504736
GNF 8647.500226
GTQ 7.712684
GYD 209.058855
HKD 7.774025
HNL 25.566404
HRK 6.8038
HTG 130.756713
HUF 364.521503
IDR 16744.7
ILS 3.697115
IMP 0.770718
INR 85.205503
IQD 1309.013652
IRR 42099.999732
ISK 130.359555
JEP 0.770718
JMD 157.390833
JOD 0.708898
JPY 145.945497
KES 129.159521
KGS 86.7116
KHR 3996.926137
KMF 450.500846
KPW 900.05404
KRW 1432.869967
KWD 0.30764
KYD 0.832746
KZT 500.949281
LAK 21648.13308
LBP 89589.614475
LKR 296.754362
LRD 199.855348
LSL 18.834644
LTL 2.95274
LVL 0.60489
LYD 4.832294
MAD 9.503842
MDL 17.846488
MGA 4557.454118
MKD 55.527732
MMK 2099.453956
MNT 3493.458295
MOP 8.006871
MRU 39.710695
MUR 45.00987
MVR 15.39681
MWK 1732.754724
MXN 19.967897
MYR 4.423498
MZN 63.910176
NAD 18.834644
NGN 1535.589882
NIO 36.768827
NOK 10.36597
NPR 136.4967
NZD 1.74723
OMR 0.384994
PAB 0.999277
PEN 3.669288
PGK 4.122593
PHP 56.849932
PKR 280.290751
PLN 3.81879
PYG 8017.358286
QAR 3.642528
RON 4.496199
RSD 105.824958
RUB 84.013876
RWF 1425.910858
SAR 3.75163
SBD 8.316332
SCR 14.301001
SDG 600.566306
SEK 9.78756
SGD 1.333125
SHP 0.785843
SLE 22.749955
SLL 20969.501083
SOS 571.105687
SRD 36.550135
STD 20697.981008
SVC 8.743332
SYP 13002.701498
SZL 18.841877
THB 34.106502
TJS 10.876865
TMT 3.5
TND 3.05759
TOP 2.3421
TRY 38.00733
TTD 6.775156
TWD 32.870221
TZS 2659.999781
UAH 41.249706
UGX 3641.623723
UYU 42.211373
UZS 12905.704728
VES 70.161515
VND 25805
VUV 123.569394
WST 2.832833
XAF 593.035892
XAG 0.031589
XAU 0.000322
XCD 2.70255
XDR 0.737546
XOF 593.035892
XPF 107.820269
YER 245.64975
ZAR 18.84945
ZMK 9001.205074
ZMW 27.754272
ZWL 321.999592
  • RBGPF

    69.0200

    69.02

    +100%

  • RELX

    0.4600

    51.44

    +0.89%

  • VOD

    0.2500

    9.37

    +2.67%

  • RYCEF

    -0.0200

    9.78

    -0.2%

  • BTI

    1.6700

    41.92

    +3.98%

  • CMSC

    -0.2400

    22.26

    -1.08%

  • NGG

    3.6100

    69.39

    +5.2%

  • GSK

    1.3700

    39.01

    +3.51%

  • RIO

    -1.4700

    58.43

    -2.52%

  • JRI

    -0.2200

    12.82

    -1.72%

  • SCS

    -0.7200

    10.74

    -6.7%

  • BCC

    -7.4400

    94.63

    -7.86%

  • AZN

    1.7000

    73.92

    +2.3%

  • BCE

    0.8400

    22.66

    +3.71%

  • BP

    -2.4700

    31.34

    -7.88%

  • CMSD

    -0.1600

    22.67

    -0.71%

EU's legal weapon facing the heat from US big tech
EU's legal weapon facing the heat from US big tech / Photo: © AFP/File

EU's legal weapon facing the heat from US big tech

For tech billionaires Elon Musk and Mark Zuckerberg, the EU's digital rules are a tool of censorship. For the bloc, they are its most powerful weapon to stop the spread of illegal content.

Text size:

The rules, known as the Digital Services Act (DSA), will be debated in the European Parliament Tuesday, as dozens of lawmakers pile pressure on Brussels to enforce measures aimed at taming the worst excesses of social media.

But the law's detractors -- including hard-right members of the EU parliament itself -- support Musk and Zuckerberg's argument, and accuse Brussels of censoring free speech.

- Is the law a tool of censorship? -

The DSA does not define what is legal or illegal online in the European Union.

What it does is force digital companies, big and small, to ensure there is an effective system in place to report and remove content that breaches existing national or EU laws.

In other words, it makes sure that if it is forbidden in the real world, it is banned on the world wide web too.

For example, Nazi symbols are outlawed in Germany while several European countries including France and the Netherlands prohibit denying the Holocaust.

EU tech chief Henna Virkkunen categorically rejects the censorship charge.

"Free speech is a fundamental value of the EU. The aim of the DSA is the protection of fundamental rights," she said on X Saturday.

- Is fact-checking obligatory? -

The DSA does not force platforms to use fact-checking to moderate online content.

The EU does however support such initiatives, considering fact-checking to be a useful tool to combat misinformation and disinformation.

At the heart of the law is a requirement for companies to subdue the risks their platforms pose, for example to children and vulnerable adults.

When Zuckerberg announced the end of Meta's US fact-checking programme, he said he would turn to "Community Notes", like those used by Musk's social media platform X.

Rather than professional fact-checkers, this model hands over the duty of debunking falsehoods to ordinary users, who can add comments and links to posts.

It is not yet known if the EU believes this system complies with the law as European regulators are currently probing its effectiveness as part of an investigation into X launched in December 2023.

- Does the DSA cover foreign interference? -

Since his outbursts against European leaders and an online chat this month with German far-right party leader Alice Weidel, Musk has attracted concerns from dozens of EU lawmakers about his "interference" in Germany's elections.

Musk's actions are allowable under EU rules protecting freedom of speech.

But the world's biggest platforms have a duty to analyse what risks their systems pose for public debate and elections, and to take steps to reduce the dangers.

The EU last month opened an investigation into TikTok following allegations it was used by Russia to sway the result of Romania's later annulled presidential election.

There are also suspicions X's algorithms are boosting far-right messages, but proving such potential biases and their impact on elections is "very difficult", said Alexandre de Streel, an expert at the Centre on Regulation in Europe think tank.

European Commission head Ursula von der Leyen has indicated she would propose new rules that would counter foreign information manipulation and interference.

- Do platforms have to consider political balance? -

Although Musk's discussion with Weidel sparked concern over the US billionaire's influence on Europe, EU officials stressed he could do as he wanted since platforms do not have to give equal airtime to different groups, unlike television.

"Platforms are not seen as traditional media," said de Streel. "There is no neutrality rule."

Musk's use of X to boost Donald Trump and European far-right figures, however, now has regulators and EU politicians asking whether to toughen the current law and force platforms to comply with similar rules on political balance.

- Can the DSA ban social media? -

The law gives the EU the right to temporarily suspend any platform -- as a last resort -- if a breach of its rules "persists and causes serious harm to users and entails criminal offences involving threat to persons' life or safety".

Before it gets that far, there are many steps the EU can take to force a platform into line, including heavy financial penalties for violations.

EU regulators can slap fines of up to six percent of a service provider's annual global turnover, which would not always be limited to the platform itself.

For example, Brussels is examining whether any fine it may decide to impose on X would include other parts of Musk's business empire such as SpaceX or Neuralink.

M.Delgado--TFWP