The Fort Worth Press - Freud, a 'mad' president and a century of European diplomacy

USD -
AED 3.67266
AFN 72.222913
ALL 91.451201
AMD 395.728672
ANG 1.801027
AOA 915.518606
ARS 1065.379897
AUD 1.596144
AWG 1.8025
AZN 1.700398
BAM 1.801236
BBD 2.01759
BDT 121.420875
BGN 1.80237
BHD 0.376962
BIF 2960.568426
BMD 1
BND 1.330257
BOB 6.920084
BRL 5.854504
BSD 0.999332
BTN 87.324618
BWP 13.652166
BYN 3.270249
BYR 19600
BZD 2.007275
CAD 1.444055
CDF 2875.000283
CHF 0.88008
CLF 0.024564
CLP 942.620275
CNY 7.260503
CNH 7.249225
COP 4181.25
CRC 503.6816
CUC 1
CUP 26.5
CVE 101.549513
CZK 23.108009
DJF 177.948463
DKK 6.880899
DOP 62.561878
DZD 133.220137
EGP 50.609899
ERN 15
ETB 128.26347
EUR 0.922545
FJD 2.300503
FKP 0.774289
GBP 0.776485
GEL 2.774993
GGP 0.774289
GHS 15.45265
GIP 0.774289
GMD 71.500047
GNF 8637.411387
GTQ 7.707746
GYD 208.983542
HKD 7.76814
HNL 25.616127
HRK 6.951904
HTG 133.030993
HUF 367.244364
IDR 16296.96735
ILS 3.645801
IMP 0.774289
INR 87.099066
IQD 1310.331451
IRR 42002.603428
ISK 135.755734
JEP 0.774289
JMD 157.055612
JOD 0.708989
JPY 147.345497
KES 129.492281
KGS 87.450039
KHR 4000.896347
KMF 454.161678
KPW 900
KRW 1449.445468
KWD 0.308601
KYD 0.820006
KZT 491.126908
LAK 21659.758467
LBP 90300.085305
LKR 295.239936
LRD 198.891857
LSL 18.208721
LTL 2.95274
LVL 0.60489
LYD 4.8262
MAD 9.737009
MDL 17.980001
MGA 4693.345651
MKD 56.580003
MMK 2099.872226
MNT 3471.226837
MOP 8.003646
MRU 39.935307
MUR 45.120143
MVR 15.460009
MWK 1733.34265
MXN 20.369185
MYR 4.415006
MZN 63.60198
NAD 18.208721
NGN 1512.41338
NIO 36.6244
NOK 10.776005
NPR 139.423829
NZD 1.76078
OMR 0.384899
PAB 1
PEN 3.656185
PGK 4.014412
PHP 57.468959
PKR 279.865636
PLN 3.847342
PYG 7940.604188
QAR 3.640089
RON 4.589691
RSD 108.094243
RUB 91.339007
RWF 1402.902997
SAR 3.749975
SBD 8.41041
SCR 14.930963
SDG 598.912484
SEK 10.12438
SGD 1.331063
SHP 0.785843
SLE 22.850317
SLL 20969.505638
SOS 571.451413
SRD 35.500001
STD 20697.981008
SVC 8.749695
SYP 13001.913453
SZL 18.208721
THB 33.60614
TJS 10.904812
TMT 3.500281
TND 3.084509
TOP 2.387202
TRY 36.58196
TTD 6.794422
TWD 32.873199
TZS 2603.468249
UAH 41.386893
UGX 3669.996496
UYU 42.43627
UZS 12918.995866
VES 64.578447
VND 25484.911769
VUV 122.506502
WST 2.807405
XAF 605.548904
XAG 0.031114
XAU 0.000345
XCD 2.7
XDR 0.751208
XOF 605.548904
XPF 110.161498
YER 248.078727
ZAR 18.319545
ZMK 9001.197478
ZMW 28.449718
ZWL 321.999592
  • RIO

    -0.1000

    62.21

    -0.16%

  • BTI

    -0.3400

    40.56

    -0.84%

  • RBGPF

    69.7700

    69.77

    +100%

  • BP

    0.1400

    32.21

    +0.43%

  • CMSC

    -0.1300

    22.98

    -0.57%

  • NGG

    1.3100

    62.14

    +2.11%

  • GSK

    0.2700

    40.32

    +0.67%

  • RYCEF

    -0.8100

    9.5

    -8.53%

  • RELX

    -0.7800

    47.32

    -1.65%

  • AZN

    -1.5100

    75.99

    -1.99%

  • VOD

    0.0300

    9.45

    +0.32%

  • BCC

    -2.4500

    99.17

    -2.47%

  • SCS

    -0.2300

    11.5

    -2%

  • CMSD

    -0.1150

    23.215

    -0.5%

  • JRI

    0.1400

    12.89

    +1.09%

  • BCE

    0.3800

    25.18

    +1.51%

Freud, a 'mad' president and a century of European diplomacy
Freud, a 'mad' president and a century of European diplomacy

Freud, a 'mad' president and a century of European diplomacy

Finding a lost manuscript by Sigmund Freud has caused a French historian to revisit a key moment in European diplomacy 100 years ago that reverberates today as war returns to the continent.

Text size:

"Le President est-il devenu fou?" (Has the president gone mad?) by Patrick Weil takes a fresh look at US president Woodrow Wilson (1913-21), who helped forge the Treaty of Versailles after World War I and tried to establish lasting peace through the creation of the League of Nations.

Wilson, of course, failed: the treaty's harsh conditions on Germany created resentment that helped fuel the rise of the Nazis.

Nor could he convince his colleagues in Washington to approve the treaty -- it was never ratified by the US, dooming the League of Nations at birth.

Back in the 1930s, Freud, the godfather of psychoanalysis, blamed Wilson's failure on messianic hubris, rooted in his repressed homosexuality and obsession with his father.

His text was not published until the 1960s, long after his death, and was rubbished by US reviewers, with The New Republic calling it either "a mischievous and preposterous joke... or else an awful and unrelenting slander upon a remarkably gifted American president".

But Weil says there may be something to Freud's critique.

- 'Hysteria' -

Whenever things went against Wilson, Weil writes, "he would plunge into hysteria", blaming everyone but himself.

Frequent minor strokes throughout Wilson's life may also have affected his sanity and undermined his ability to conclude the deal.

Certainly, many of his contemporaries, including British leader Winston Churchill and later US president Franklin Roosevelt, considered Wilson to be "crazy", Weil told AFP in an interview.

They kept that quiet, he said, because Wilson's reputation was important in building momentum behind the creation of the United Nations after World War II.

Weil uncovered Freud's original manuscript in an unmarked box in the archives of Yale University.

Freud had co-written his tract with a US diplomat, William Bullitt, and the original shows that some 300 changes were made by Bullitt before it was finally published in the 1960s, cutting many key psychological insights.

Weil uses his finding to help reassess the debate around the Treaty of Versailles -- a story with grim relevance now as the world seeks ways to negotiate with Russia.

"One can't help noticing how the personality of certain leaders plays a role in the dangers faced by the world -- today as much as yesterday," he said.

- 'NATO before the fact' -

France's prime minister in 1919, Georges Clemenceau, is often blamed for pushing too hard to punish Germany, wanting to crush any chance of its resurgence -- a move that spectacularly backfired.

But Weil puts a different spin on events, having dug up documents that show that France's primary aim was to win security guarantees from the US and Britain -- a sort of early form of NATO -- in case of future German aggression.

"It is NATO before the fact, and it is a French request to create it," Weil said.

Wilson's failure to see the importance of a defence pact -- or to convince his colleagues in Washington -- ultimately doomed Europe to more war, he argues.

"It was an obsession of Roosevelt (during World War II) not to commit the same mistakes," said Weil.

"What's important in today's context is that the leaders in 1945 had that experience of 1919. Churchill, Roosevelt -- they were there (at Versailles).

"They had that experience that today's leaders do not."

W.Matthews--TFWP