The Fort Worth Press - Can Hermes and Nike stop 'unauthorised' NFTs?

USD -
AED 3.673051
AFN 67.000198
ALL 92.450129
AMD 386.974854
ANG 1.802123
AOA 912.000177
ARS 1000.362898
AUD 1.543841
AWG 1.8025
AZN 1.691881
BAM 1.857325
BBD 2.01886
BDT 119.48491
BGN 1.852673
BHD 0.37685
BIF 2897.5
BMD 1
BND 1.345641
BOB 6.908832
BRL 5.782302
BSD 0.999886
BTN 84.392794
BWP 13.725155
BYN 3.272208
BYR 19600
BZD 2.01548
CAD 1.402975
CDF 2866.000089
CHF 0.88797
CLF 0.035343
CLP 975.229905
CNY 7.230299
CNH 7.244025
COP 4483.25
CRC 510.721544
CUC 1
CUP 26.5
CVE 104.903343
CZK 23.953046
DJF 177.720183
DKK 7.06422
DOP 60.450092
DZD 133.619613
EGP 49.468904
ERN 15
ETB 122.050129
EUR 0.94716
FJD 2.275017
FKP 0.789317
GBP 0.78725
GEL 2.724958
GGP 0.789317
GHS 16.049785
GIP 0.789317
GMD 71.000218
GNF 8630.99963
GTQ 7.721894
GYD 209.184836
HKD 7.781925
HNL 25.060355
HRK 7.133259
HTG 131.382772
HUF 384.7675
IDR 15929.25
ILS 3.74008
IMP 0.789317
INR 84.46215
IQD 1310.5
IRR 42105.000021
ISK 137.989828
JEP 0.789317
JMD 158.287592
JOD 0.709103
JPY 155.788976
KES 129.506089
KGS 86.376501
KHR 4051.000265
KMF 466.495264
KPW 899.999621
KRW 1403.499466
KWD 0.30742
KYD 0.833207
KZT 495.71708
LAK 21944.999806
LBP 89600.000301
LKR 292.121707
LRD 184.097004
LSL 18.249887
LTL 2.95274
LVL 0.60489
LYD 4.870249
MAD 9.958049
MDL 18.112322
MGA 4655.000126
MKD 58.237769
MMK 3247.960992
MNT 3397.999946
MOP 8.01546
MRU 39.874993
MUR 47.190157
MVR 15.449695
MWK 1735.99992
MXN 20.46769
MYR 4.480502
MZN 63.901556
NAD 18.250431
NGN 1679.859944
NIO 36.779633
NOK 11.10269
NPR 135.033904
NZD 1.702273
OMR 0.385021
PAB 0.999905
PEN 3.804497
PGK 3.93475
PHP 58.856502
PKR 278.04999
PLN 4.095903
PYG 7808.968491
QAR 3.64055
RON 4.712597
RSD 110.634002
RUB 99.304003
RWF 1365
SAR 3.755981
SBD 8.383555
SCR 13.598198
SDG 601.498491
SEK 10.956202
SGD 1.343095
SHP 0.789317
SLE 22.680291
SLL 20969.504736
SOS 571.504424
SRD 35.3565
STD 20697.981008
SVC 8.749122
SYP 2512.529858
SZL 18.249753
THB 34.870301
TJS 10.658475
TMT 3.51
TND 3.151967
TOP 2.342098
TRY 34.327599
TTD 6.789045
TWD 32.579498
TZS 2660.000424
UAH 41.219825
UGX 3669.445974
UYU 42.477826
UZS 12824.999812
VES 44.994212
VND 25400
VUV 118.722009
WST 2.791591
XAF 622.917458
XAG 0.032786
XAU 0.000389
XCD 2.70255
XDR 0.753255
XOF 616.501263
XPF 113.349704
YER 249.849944
ZAR 18.199145
ZMK 9001.199107
ZMW 27.421652
ZWL 321.999592
  • RIO

    -0.1500

    60.47

    -0.25%

  • CMSC

    0.0490

    24.659

    +0.2%

  • BTI

    0.2100

    35.63

    +0.59%

  • SCS

    -0.1650

    13.205

    -1.25%

  • CMSD

    -0.0200

    24.71

    -0.08%

  • BCC

    -2.5200

    140.03

    -1.8%

  • BCE

    -0.2700

    26.94

    -1%

  • NGG

    0.5900

    62.71

    +0.94%

  • RBGPF

    -0.9400

    59.25

    -1.59%

  • JRI

    -0.0100

    13.23

    -0.08%

  • RYCEF

    -0.2300

    6.88

    -3.34%

  • BP

    0.4600

    29.03

    +1.58%

  • GSK

    -0.0150

    35.095

    -0.04%

  • AZN

    0.6000

    65.89

    +0.91%

  • VOD

    -0.0250

    8.725

    -0.29%

  • RELX

    0.0450

    46.165

    +0.1%

Can Hermes and Nike stop 'unauthorised' NFTs?
Can Hermes and Nike stop 'unauthorised' NFTs?

Can Hermes and Nike stop 'unauthorised' NFTs?

As digital objects in the form of NFTs have exploded in popularity and value over the past year, so too have the legal headaches and complications.

Text size:

Nike became the latest company to file a lawsuit over the issue on Thursday -- suing shopping platform StockX for creating and marketing NFTs with its logo and branding.

It follows a lawsuit last month by French luxury brand Hermes against artist Mason Rothschild, who has auctioned 100 "MetaBirkins" -- a digital "homage" to the label's famous Birkin bag -- some fetching tens of thousands of dollars.

- Can these cases succeed?

The Hermes case could go either way, said lawyer Annabelle Gauberti, whose firm Crefovi specialises in creative industries.

Rothschild has argued that he is protected by the First Amendment as an artist, which often has validity in US courts.

In Europe, too: Gauberti recalled the example of a case from a decade ago in which Louis Vuitton lost in its attempts to prevent a Dutch artist placing one of its bags in a picture of a Darfur refugee.

"The 'fair use' defence works well, particularly in UK and US law, in which an artist can use a trademarked word or product to make a point or as a parody," Gauberti said.

But she said Rothschild may struggle to convince a judge that his work had artistic merit.

"It's hard to see on the face of it what message he is trying to convey other than that he wants to make a lot of money, so it's going to be a lot of work for his legal team," she said.

The Nike case is a more directly commercial affair, since StockX has never claimed its NFTs are a form of art.

But it remains to be seen how trademark law holds up in the digital realm.

"The extent of these protections in the digital world as well as what remedies can be granted are yet to be explored," wrote lawyer Danielle Garno in a briefing note for Lexology.

- Should NFTs be treated differently to physical art?

In his response to Hermes, published on Twitter, Rothschild compared his MetaBirkins to Andy Warhol's famous Campbell soup paintings.

"The fact that I sell the art using NFTs doesn't change the fact that it's art," he wrote in a response published on Twitter.

However, Edward Lee of Chicago-Kent College of Law told Bloomberg Law that the Warhol comparison was not perfect since the Campbell Soup Co. was never likely to get into the business of selling paintings, whereas Hermes could well choose to create its own NFTs.

The technology can also confuse matters, since an NFT is actually just a receipt of ownership, rather than the thing itself.

"Many people assume that, when you talk about an NFT, the content of the NFT is inside the token, which it is not, and because it is not, there is no unauthorised reproduction," Primavera De Filippi, co-author of "Blockchain and the Law", told Business of Fashion magazine.

- What can companies do to protect themselves? -

Hermes has demanded that Rothschild remove and destroy his MetaBirkins, and at least one NFT platform, OpenSea, has already agreed to remove them from sale.

But Gauberti said enforcing the law online is very tricky.

"Even if lawsuits are successful, how do you go after the guy who has already bought the item or stop them being sold on secondary auctions? It's the wild west in terms of enforcement online," she said.

The best option, she said, is for brands to get ahead of the copycats and dominate the space with "official" NFTs.

Nike has done exactly that, acquiring RTFKT, a company that specialises in designing digital sneakers, in December.

"A strong offence is the best defence," said Gauberti.

"At the moment, a lot of these brands are on the fence (about creating their own NFTs) because their core products are physical, and they're still watching the space to see if the metaverse will really take off."

J.Ayala--TFWP