The Fort Worth Press - Herbicide under US scrutiny over potential Parkinson's link

USD -
AED 3.673035
AFN 71.323752
ALL 89.53094
AMD 391.220245
ANG 1.790208
AOA 915.999913
ARS 1073.328206
AUD 1.648685
AWG 1.8
AZN 1.697294
BAM 1.766685
BBD 2.011533
BDT 121.061023
BGN 1.780804
BHD 0.376912
BIF 2961.474188
BMD 1
BND 1.332099
BOB 6.885493
BRL 5.798599
BSD 0.996193
BTN 84.992526
BWP 13.874477
BYN 3.260694
BYR 19600
BZD 2.001147
CAD 1.41989
CDF 2873.000251
CHF 0.855989
CLF 0.025105
CLP 963.28003
CNY 7.28155
CNH 7.284495
COP 4213.64
CRC 503.907996
CUC 1
CUP 26.5
CVE 99.605696
CZK 22.9045
DJF 177.409085
DKK 6.79033
DOP 62.907224
DZD 133.545031
EGP 50.6056
ERN 15
ETB 131.300523
EUR 0.91017
FJD 2.314901
FKP 0.762682
GBP 0.77279
GEL 2.749975
GGP 0.762682
GHS 15.48644
GIP 0.762682
GMD 72.139607
GNF 8645.949925
GTQ 7.693185
GYD 209.183137
HKD 7.775095
HNL 25.577483
HRK 6.860199
HTG 130.793752
HUF 364.387873
IDR 16744.473258
ILS 3.73789
IMP 0.762682
INR 85.338154
IQD 1306.506853
IRR 42336.988543
ISK 130.567142
JEP 0.762682
JMD 157.094395
JOD 0.709023
JPY 145.7695
KES 129.238254
KGS 86.692362
KHR 3971.595158
KMF 445.147581
KPW 899.928114
KRW 1451.374019
KWD 0.307615
KYD 0.83156
KZT 501.917416
LAK 21606.921497
LBP 89544.522786
LKR 295.184792
LRD 199.781411
LSL 18.739948
LTL 2.95274
LVL 0.60489
LYD 4.82245
MAD 9.516652
MDL 17.902827
MGA 4631.875059
MKD 56.260592
MMK 2099.545327
MNT 3504.730669
MOP 8.010542
MRU 39.660628
MUR 45.370989
MVR 15.441096
MWK 1732.00408
MXN 20.47753
MYR 4.442621
MZN 63.8826
NAD 18.739948
NGN 1536.123004
NIO 36.754903
NOK 10.71859
NPR 136.60505
NZD 1.78242
OMR 0.384952
PAB 1
PEN 3.666345
PGK 4.106218
PHP 57.053122
PKR 279.986588
PLN 3.82525
PYG 7937.001208
QAR 3.64001
RON 4.504564
RSD 106.000243
RUB 84.082892
RWF 1417.183198
SAR 3.749834
SBD 8.499278
SCR 14.328056
SDG 600.377285
SEK 10.00087
SGD 1.334705
SHP 0.785843
SLE 22.749784
SLL 20969.501083
SOS 569.677964
SRD 36.564761
STD 20697.981008
SVC 8.750011
SYP 13001.416834
SZL 18.739948
THB 34.107305
TJS 10.883523
TMT 3.497769
TND 3.055277
TOP 2.408314
TRY 38.002335
TTD 6.752072
TWD 33.07735
TZS 2654.318194
UAH 41.285264
UGX 3652.036928
UYU 42.304314
UZS 12908.018961
VES 70.043118
VND 25805.374257
VUV 123.606268
WST 2.823884
XAF 593.530108
XAG 0.033559
XAU 0.000329
XCD 2.707263
XDR 0.753961
XOF 593.530108
XPF 107.975038
YER 245.884458
ZAR 19.037395
ZMK 9001.204849
ZMW 27.959236
ZWL 321.999592
  • CMSC

    -0.1630

    22.097

    -0.74%

  • RBGPF

    1.0200

    69.02

    +1.48%

  • CMSD

    -0.0430

    22.627

    -0.19%

  • NGG

    -2.6200

    66.77

    -3.92%

  • SCS

    -0.2700

    10.47

    -2.58%

  • GSK

    -2.1600

    36.85

    -5.86%

  • BCC

    -1.0100

    93.62

    -1.08%

  • AZN

    -4.8600

    69.06

    -7.04%

  • RIO

    -3.6700

    54.76

    -6.7%

  • BTI

    -1.5000

    40.42

    -3.71%

  • BCE

    0.2250

    22.885

    +0.98%

  • VOD

    -0.7950

    8.575

    -9.27%

  • RYCEF

    -1.3900

    8.41

    -16.53%

  • RELX

    -2.3500

    49.09

    -4.79%

  • JRI

    -0.8000

    12.02

    -6.66%

  • BP

    -2.7150

    28.625

    -9.48%

Herbicide under US scrutiny over potential Parkinson's link
Herbicide under US scrutiny over potential Parkinson's link / Photo: © David Jilbert/AFP

Herbicide under US scrutiny over potential Parkinson's link

First came the slow hand movements, then the tremor, and now the looming fear of what lies ahead.

Text size:

David Jilbert's devastating diagnosis of Parkinson's disease three years ago changed his life irrevocably -- and it's a condition the 65-year-old farmer believes he wouldn't have if it weren't for paraquat, a herbicide he once relied on to control weeds in his vineyard in the midwestern US state of Ohio.

"Now it's not just about me, I'm part of this community -- let's get something going," Jilbert said during a recent hearing in the US Congress on the issue.

Banned in more than 70 countries -- including Britain, where it is manufactured; Switzerland, home to the Syngenta company that owns the brand; and China, where the state-run conglomerate that owns Syngenta is based -- paraquat remains available in the United States.

The US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has long maintained that the herbicide is safe for use under strict regulations -- something Parkinson's advocates are hoping to change.

The agency is set to issue a final report on the issue by January 17, 2025, a date mandated by a court in response to 90 new scientific studies submitted by the Michael J. Fox Foundation and other groups.

- Industry denies causation -

"We have great sympathy for those suffering from the debilitating effects of Parkinson's disease," a spokesperson for Syngenta said in a statement to AFP.

"However, it is important to note that the scientific evidence simply does not support a causal link between paraquat and Parkinson's disease, and that paraquat is safe when used as directed."

Multiple credible studies have found that agricultural workers who handle paraquat -- or live near areas where it is applied -- face a higher incidence of Parkinson's disease, which can eventually turn even the simplest movements into daunting challenges.

Animal research further underscores paraquat's toxic effects on nerve cells, although proving direct causation for individuals remains difficult.

"I find it extraordinarily frustrating that the chemical companies have hidden behind the concept of being able to show causation, and they've used that as an excuse, because we haven't been able to come out and definitively say that," Australia-based neurologist David Blacker said in interview with Pesticide Action UK, an advocacy group.

"That's where the precautionary principle comes in," he added. "If there is a doubt, especially if there are alternatives, it then becomes, in my mind, ethically and even morally unsound to continue to pursue."

- 'It's scary' -

Jilbert, a longtime environmental engineer and environmental safety inspector, dreamed of becoming a farmer after retirement.

In 2011, he purchased his land and, over the following years, began using paraquat -- often sold as Gramoxone -- to manage his weeds. By the end of the decade, he noticed his hands moving slowly and his gait turning into a shuffle.

When his Parkinson's diagnosis finally came, he was horrified and wondered if he'd been condemned to a "death sentence." His condition is more manageable for now, thanks to medications, but he says he feels disappointed in his own government for not looking out for him.

"You think if you use the stuff in the way the label tells me to use it, then I'm not going to get sick," he said.

Like Jilbert, 85-year-old Charlene Tenbrink -- who owns a 250-acre farm in Dixon, California -- also trusted that the chemicals available to farmers were safe when handled properly.

She sprayed paraquat on her prune trees in the 1990s and was diagnosed with Parkinson's in 2020.

Tenbrink, Jilbert and thousands of others are now suing Syngenta in federal and California state courts.

Sarah Doles, a lawyer and co-lead for that federal litigation, compared it to the cases against Big Tobacco. She contends Syngenta had a legal duty to disclose harms its own teams knew about paraquat from research going back decades, but hid from consumers.

"It's a legal duty of what they knew and then failed to do -- they concealed the information," she told AFP.

Regardless of which direction the EPA rules, these legal cases will continue.

Tenbrink says it's vital to get the product off the market, and admits she's terrified for her own future.

"This is a terrible disease and we know there's no cure, we know it's going to get worse. It's scary," she says.

W.Matthews--TFWP