The Fort Worth Press - For profit or for all? Argentine football clubs red-card Milei reforms

USD -
AED 3.67299
AFN 67.946782
ALL 93.207221
AMD 386.974854
ANG 1.802123
AOA 910.98202
ARS 998.755701
AUD 1.544354
AWG 1.8
AZN 1.691712
BAM 1.857325
BBD 2.01886
BDT 119.48491
BGN 1.854553
BHD 0.376879
BIF 2952.762636
BMD 1
BND 1.345641
BOB 6.908832
BRL 5.776602
BSD 0.999886
BTN 84.392794
BWP 13.725155
BYN 3.272208
BYR 19600
BZD 2.01548
CAD 1.402545
CDF 2865.000434
CHF 0.887495
CLF 0.035562
CLP 981.309839
CNY 7.230099
CNH 7.24008
COP 4475.83
CRC 510.721544
CUC 1
CUP 26.5
CVE 104.713111
CZK 23.944974
DJF 178.046418
DKK 7.06352
DOP 60.473685
DZD 133.681663
EGP 49.353204
ERN 15
ETB 123.94359
EUR 0.94701
FJD 2.27435
FKP 0.789317
GBP 0.78787
GEL 2.730102
GGP 0.789317
GHS 16.072666
GIP 0.789317
GMD 71.00036
GNF 8618.069932
GTQ 7.721894
GYD 209.184836
HKD 7.78008
HNL 25.247384
HRK 7.133259
HTG 131.382772
HUF 384.544017
IDR 15914.7
ILS 3.738105
IMP 0.789317
INR 84.433902
IQD 1309.851665
IRR 42092.497889
ISK 138.320354
JEP 0.789317
JMD 158.287592
JOD 0.709098
JPY 155.767044
KES 129.250012
KGS 86.3765
KHR 4061.574109
KMF 466.349718
KPW 899.999621
KRW 1400.903561
KWD 0.307599
KYD 0.833207
KZT 495.71708
LAK 21965.811966
LBP 89540.45584
LKR 292.121707
LRD 184.475424
LSL 18.302027
LTL 2.95274
LVL 0.60489
LYD 4.884048
MAD 9.98661
MDL 18.112322
MGA 4684.710351
MKD 58.241904
MMK 3247.960992
MNT 3397.999946
MOP 8.01546
MRU 39.750432
MUR 47.190196
MVR 15.449715
MWK 1733.742308
MXN 20.587085
MYR 4.480497
MZN 63.897759
NAD 18.302027
NGN 1679.85963
NIO 36.800319
NOK 11.123215
NPR 135.033904
NZD 1.702345
OMR 0.385033
PAB 0.999905
PEN 3.810139
PGK 3.961938
PHP 58.753497
PKR 277.715048
PLN 4.09533
PYG 7808.968491
QAR 3.64504
RON 4.711401
RSD 110.814981
RUB 99.499055
RWF 1372.787359
SAR 3.756074
SBD 8.383555
SCR 13.598533
SDG 601.506089
SEK 10.984197
SGD 1.342375
SHP 0.789317
SLE 22.814974
SLL 20969.504736
SOS 571.404152
SRD 35.356496
STD 20697.981008
SVC 8.749122
SYP 2512.529858
SZL 18.309939
THB 34.855016
TJS 10.658475
TMT 3.51
TND 3.157965
TOP 2.342096
TRY 34.34758
TTD 6.789045
TWD 32.561028
TZS 2659.999759
UAH 41.219825
UGX 3669.445974
UYU 42.477826
UZS 12806.024577
VES 44.994614
VND 25400
VUV 118.722009
WST 2.791591
XAF 622.917458
XAG 0.032948
XAU 0.00039
XCD 2.70255
XDR 0.753255
XOF 622.958869
XPF 113.255209
YER 249.801597
ZAR 18.24247
ZMK 9001.209182
ZMW 27.421652
ZWL 321.999592
  • CMSC

    0.0250

    24.635

    +0.1%

  • SCS

    -0.2100

    13.16

    -1.6%

  • AZN

    0.6600

    65.95

    +1%

  • NGG

    0.5000

    62.62

    +0.8%

  • BP

    0.3400

    28.91

    +1.18%

  • BTI

    0.2550

    35.675

    +0.71%

  • RIO

    -0.1350

    60.485

    -0.22%

  • GSK

    0.0050

    35.115

    +0.01%

  • CMSD

    0.0170

    24.747

    +0.07%

  • RBGPF

    -0.9400

    59.25

    -1.59%

  • RYCEF

    -0.2300

    6.88

    -3.34%

  • BCC

    -3.0000

    139.55

    -2.15%

  • JRI

    -0.0500

    13.19

    -0.38%

  • BCE

    -0.1050

    27.105

    -0.39%

  • RELX

    0.0770

    46.197

    +0.17%

  • VOD

    -0.0200

    8.73

    -0.23%

For profit or for all? Argentine football clubs red-card Milei reforms
For profit or for all? Argentine football clubs red-card Milei reforms / Photo: © AFP

For profit or for all? Argentine football clubs red-card Milei reforms

A debate over the soul of football is raging in World Cup holders Argentina, pitting defenders of the social role of the beautiful game against the government of libertarian President Javier Milei, who wants to turn clubs into for-profit companies.

Text size:

Argentina, which gave the world Diego Maradona and Lionel Messi, is home to some of the world's most devoted football fans -- a fact attributed by supporters like Gabriel Nicosia to the clubs' community outreach.

Nicosia is a lifelong supporter of San Lorenzo, a more-than-century-old first division club based in the working-class Buenos Aires neighborhood of Boedo where he grew up.

Several times a week he crosses town to have a coffee or work out in the club of which Argentina-born Pope Francis is a fan.

"When I come here I meet my childhood friends. It's a fundamental pillar of everyday life," says the 50-year-old accountant, one of 80,000 members of a club whose stadium can only seat 48,000.

Membership can be acquired for a modest 22,000 pesos ($21) a month and comes with a vote on the club's management and tickets to local games.

The club's role as the glue that binds the community is underscored by the 300 scholarships it awards each year to young people from a nearby shantytown.

The recipients get to indulge their own dreams of fame and fortune by hanging out close to the training grounds of millionaire players.

Advocates of the not-for-profit model fear that this outreach could become a thing of the past if Milei manages to impose his free-marketeer vision on the clubs.

The president, an ardent defender of deregulation in all spheres of society, wants to change the statutes of the country's several thousand football clubs to allow them to become privately-owned for-profit companies.

- 'No-one cares' about owners -

During campaigning for president last year, Milei cited Buenos Aires' famous Boca Juniors, of which he is a fan, in arguing: "No-one cares who the owner is if you beat (arch-rivals) River Plate 5-0 and you win the Club World Cup."

The alternative, he said, was to "live with the misery that is Argentine football, which is deteriorating by the day."

He has pointed to Europe's top clubs, several of which are owned by Gulf states or, were previously, by Russian oligarchs as a model for his country.

But many Argentine clubs are firmly opposed to any change of ownership.

- Court setback for Milei -

"Our club belongs to its people, its members and its partners who make it greater each day," was Boca Juniors' rejoinder.

Argentine Football Association (AFA) president Claudio Tapia, who has one World Cup (2022) and two Copa America (2021, 2024) titles under his belt, has also made no secret of his opposition to the reforms.

It's "not our football model," Tapia, whose re-election to another four-year term in October was seen as a rebuke to Milei's reform, told an AFA assembly in August.

The president, a self-described "anarcho-capitalist", has forged ahead regardless.

In August, his government ordered the AFA to amend its statutes to allow for-profit clubs to join.

The decree was suspended by a court in September pending the outcome of a legal challenge by the AFA.

- Following Brazil's lead -

In Latin America, the pressure on clubs to open up to private investors is not unique to Argentina.

In 2021, Brazil changed its laws to allow for-profit clubs and Argentina's neighbour Uruguay has also adopted the model.

Some clubs see outside investment as a way to grow, attract new talent and ensure their funding into the future.

Membership fees "are not enough" to cover a club's costs, San Lorenzo director Martin Cigna said, adding that without TV rights and transfer fees his club would be running "a million-dollar deficit."

Former Argentina international Juan Sebastian Veron, who is president of another venerable club, Estudiantes, said they were preparing for a change to a "hybrid" model that would combine a "social" role with private funding.

Sports sociologist Veronica Moreira warned that a for-profit model would jeopardize club's non-commercial activities, with investors likely to "close anything that does not make a profit."

The ball is still up in the air but tensions are rising between the AFA and Milei.

The president has vowed to investigate "irregularities" at the AFA, whose leadership he has compared to that of authoritarian Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro.

But for the moment, football fans are on the AFA's side.

A poll carried out by the sports think tank Tactica showed 60.2 percent of Argentines interested in the sport opposed a change in the clubs' ownership.

J.Barnes--TFWP