The Fort Worth Press - Prosecutors can use rap lyrics as evidence in Young Thug trial, judge rules

USD -
AED 3.673007
AFN 68.858766
ALL 88.802398
AMD 387.151613
ANG 1.799401
AOA 927.769004
ARS 961.242518
AUD 1.46886
AWG 1.8
AZN 1.702679
BAM 1.749922
BBD 2.015926
BDT 119.312844
BGN 1.749922
BHD 0.376236
BIF 2894.376594
BMD 1
BND 1.290118
BOB 6.899298
BRL 5.515103
BSD 0.998434
BTN 83.448933
BWP 13.198228
BYN 3.267481
BYR 19600
BZD 2.012526
CAD 1.35775
CDF 2870.999563
CHF 0.849991
CLF 0.033646
CLP 928.403346
CNY 7.051902
CNH 7.043005
COP 4153.983805
CRC 518.051268
CUC 1
CUP 26.5
CVE 98.657898
CZK 22.451401
DJF 177.79269
DKK 6.682022
DOP 59.929316
DZD 132.138863
EGP 48.452557
ERN 15
ETB 115.859974
EUR 0.894902
FJD 2.200802
FKP 0.761559
GBP 0.75061
GEL 2.730259
GGP 0.761559
GHS 15.696327
GIP 0.761559
GMD 68.503571
GNF 8626.135194
GTQ 7.71798
GYD 208.866819
HKD 7.79135
HNL 24.767145
HRK 6.799011
HTG 131.740706
HUF 352.15979
IDR 15160.8
ILS 3.781915
IMP 0.761559
INR 83.48045
IQD 1307.922874
IRR 42092.502571
ISK 136.259765
JEP 0.761559
JMD 156.86485
JOD 0.708497
JPY 143.825011
KES 128.797029
KGS 84.238496
KHR 4054.936698
KMF 441.350254
KPW 899.999433
KRW 1332.489635
KWD 0.30507
KYD 0.832014
KZT 478.691898
LAK 22047.152507
LBP 89409.743659
LKR 304.621304
LRD 199.686843
LSL 17.527759
LTL 2.95274
LVL 0.60489
LYD 4.741198
MAD 9.681206
MDL 17.42227
MGA 4515.724959
MKD 55.129065
MMK 3247.960992
MNT 3397.999955
MOP 8.014495
MRU 39.677896
MUR 45.879786
MVR 15.360271
MWK 1731.132286
MXN 19.414798
MYR 4.204968
MZN 63.850233
NAD 17.527759
NGN 1639.450068
NIO 36.746745
NOK 10.48375
NPR 133.518543
NZD 1.60295
OMR 0.384512
PAB 0.998434
PEN 3.742316
PGK 3.9082
PHP 55.653017
PKR 277.414933
PLN 3.82535
PYG 7789.558449
QAR 3.640048
RON 4.449903
RSD 104.761777
RUB 92.515546
RWF 1345.94909
SAR 3.752452
SBD 8.306937
SCR 13.046124
SDG 601.503002
SEK 10.171203
SGD 1.291297
SHP 0.761559
SLE 22.847303
SLL 20969.494858
SOS 570.572183
SRD 30.20498
STD 20697.981008
SVC 8.736188
SYP 2512.529936
SZL 17.534112
THB 32.926959
TJS 10.61334
TMT 3.5
TND 3.025276
TOP 2.342102
TRY 34.117503
TTD 6.791035
TWD 31.980979
TZS 2725.719143
UAH 41.267749
UGX 3698.832371
UYU 41.256207
UZS 12705.229723
VEF 3622552.534434
VES 36.777762
VND 24605
VUV 118.722009
WST 2.797463
XAF 586.90735
XAG 0.03211
XAU 0.000381
XCD 2.70255
XDR 0.739945
XOF 586.90735
XPF 106.706035
YER 250.325005
ZAR 17.43086
ZMK 9001.200893
ZMW 26.433141
ZWL 321.999592
  • BCE

    -0.1500

    35.04

    -0.43%

  • CMSD

    0.0100

    25.02

    +0.04%

  • GSK

    -0.8200

    40.8

    -2.01%

  • BCC

    -7.1900

    137.5

    -5.23%

  • NGG

    0.7200

    69.55

    +1.04%

  • SCS

    -0.3900

    12.92

    -3.02%

  • BTI

    -0.1300

    37.44

    -0.35%

  • CMSC

    0.0300

    25.15

    +0.12%

  • AZN

    -0.5200

    78.38

    -0.66%

  • RIO

    -1.6100

    63.57

    -2.53%

  • JRI

    -0.0800

    13.32

    -0.6%

  • RELX

    -0.1400

    47.99

    -0.29%

  • RBGPF

    58.8300

    58.83

    +100%

  • VOD

    -0.0500

    10.01

    -0.5%

  • RYCEF

    0.0200

    6.97

    +0.29%

  • BP

    -0.1200

    32.64

    -0.37%

Prosecutors can use rap lyrics as evidence in Young Thug trial, judge rules
Prosecutors can use rap lyrics as evidence in Young Thug trial, judge rules / Photo: © AFP/File

Prosecutors can use rap lyrics as evidence in Young Thug trial, judge rules

Rap lyrics can be admitted as evidence in the sprawling US gang conspiracy trial targeting rapper Young Thug and several others, a judge ruled Thursday.

Text size:

The defense had sought to exclude lyrics from evidence, saying the use of verses could unfairly influence the jury and was a violation of creative expression.

For years, many free speech advocates, civil rights groups, music world figures and legislators have decried using lyrics as evidence as a constitutional violation of expression that criminalizes and punishes artists, most of them of color.

But Atlanta Judge Ural Glanville ruled that he would allow specific sets of lyrics as evidence if prosecutors could detail how the raps connected to crimes the defendants are alleged to have committed.

There are 17 sets of lyrics Glanville said he would plan to admit, and that additional verses could be presented if prosecutors can "lay the foundation" of how they connect to alleged real-life crimes.

Young Thug, the 32-year-old rapper born Jeffery Williams, was one of 28 alleged street gang members originally swept up in a May 2022 racketeering indictment. Many of those defendants have since taken plea deals or will be tried separately.

The accusations included myriad predicate offenses that support an overarching conspiracy charge, including murder, assault, carjacking, drug dealing and theft.

Prosecutors say Young Thug's record label is a front for a crime ring, arguing that the defendants belong to a branch of the Bloods street gang identified as Young Slime Life, or YSL.

But defense lawyers insist YSL -- Young Stoner Life Records, a hip-hop and trap label that Young Thug founded in 2016 -- is simply a music label and vague association of artists, not a gang.

The indictment shook the rap world in Atlanta, where Young Thug is considered among the industry's most impactful figures.

The jury selection process took nearly 10 months, a painstaking process marred by delays.

Opening statements are currently scheduled for November 27, and the trial could last well into 2024. Young Thug is on trial in Fulton County court in Georgia, the same jurisdiction where former president Donald Trump is also embroiled in a racketeering case.

- 'Fictional art form' -

The admission of rap lyrics as evidence will surely continue to trigger debate, both in the courtroom and across the broader music world.

Critics of the tactic say taking slice-of-life lyrics out of context criminalizes artists who are primarily Black and brown, and can have a chilling effect on creative expression.

During hours of presentation on Wednesday prosecutor Mike Carlson told the judge "the question is not rap lyrics. The question is gang lyrics."

"These are party admissions. They just happen to come in the form of lyrics."

Fellow prosecutor Simone Hylton read the lyrics aloud to Judge Glanville on Wednesday, saying they glorify alleged crimes, including the shootings of rival gang members and violence against police.

But the defense argued that lyrics are fiction.

"Rap is the only fictional art form treated this way," said attorney Doug Weinstein, who represents the artist Yak Gotti.

"No other musical genre, no other art is treated the same way."

The defense also said the lyrics could unjustly influence the jury: "As soon as you put these lyrics in front of a jury the blinders drop," said Weinstein.

"They’re going to look at these lyrics and instantly say they are guilty."

D.Johnson--TFWP